Prior to the 1957-58 season, All-America teams were named by coaches, rather than chosen through a formal vote of the American Hockey Coaches Association.
| Year | Student-athlete | Team | Year | Student-athlete | Team |
| 1949-50 |
Buzz Johnson, F |
2nd | 1989-90 |
Russ Parent, D |
1st |
| Dan McKinnon, D |
2nd |
Lee Davidson, C |
2nd | ||
| 1950-51 |
John Noah, D | 1st | 1990-91 |
Greg Johnson, C |
1st |
| 1951-52 |
Ben Cherski, C |
2nd | 1991-92 |
Greg Johnson, C |
2nd |
| 1952-53 |
Ben Cherski, C |
1st | 1992-93 |
Greg Johnson, C |
1st |
| 1953-54 |
Ben Cherski, C |
1st | 1995-96 |
Teeder Wynne, F |
2nd |
| Spike Schultz, G |
1st | 1996-97 |
Curtis Murphy, D |
2nd | |
| 1954-55 |
Bill Reichart, C |
1st |
David Hoogsteen, F |
2nd | |
| 1955-56 |
Bill Reichart, C | 1st | 1997-98 |
Curtis Murphy, D |
1st |
| 1956-57 |
Bill Reichart, F |
1st | Jason Blake, F |
2nd | |
| Bill Steenson, D |
1st | Karl Goehring, G |
2nd | ||
| 1957-58 |
Bill Steenson, D |
1st | 1998-99 |
Jason Blake, C | 1st |
| 1958-59 |
Bill Steenson, D |
1st | Brad Williamson, D |
1st | |
| 1959-60 |
Reg Morelli, C |
1st | Jay Panzer, F |
2nd | |
| 1962-63 |
Don Ross, D |
1st | 1999-00 |
Karl Goehring, G | 1st |
| Al McLean, F |
1st | Jeff Panzer, C |
1st | ||
| Dave Merrifield, F |
1st | Lee Goren, F |
2nd | ||
| 1964-65 |
Don Ross, D |
1st | 2000-01 |
Jeff Panzer, C |
1st |
| 1965-66 |
Terry Casey, C | 1st | Travis Roche, D |
1st | |
| 1966-67 |
Jerry Lafond, D |
1st | Bryan Lundbohm, W |
2nd | |
| 1967-68 |
Terry Abram, D |
1st | 2003-04 |
Brandon Bochenski, W |
1st |
| Bob Munro, C |
1st | Zach Parise, C |
1st | ||
| 1968-69 |
Bob Munro, C |
1st | 2006-07 |
Ryan Duncan, F |
1st |
| John Marks, D |
1st | Jonathan Toews, F |
1st | ||
| 1969-70 |
John Marks, D |
1st | Taylor Chorney, D |
2nd | |
| 1971-72 |
Alan Hangsleben, D |
1st | 2007-08 |
T.J. Oshie, F |
1st |
| 1978-79 |
Bob Iwabuchi, G |
1st | 2008-09 |
Chay Genoway, D |
2nd |
| Kevin Maxwell, C |
1st | ||||
| 1979-80 |
Mark Taylor, C | 1st | |||
| Howard Walker, D |
1st | ||||
| 1980-81 |
Marc Chorney, D |
1st | |||
| 1982-83 |
James Patrick, D |
1st | |||
| 1983-84 |
Jon Casey, G |
1st | |||
| 1985-86 |
Scott Sandelin, D |
2nd | |||
| 1986-87 |
Tony Hrkac, C |
1st | |||
| Bob Joyce, F |
1st | ||||
| Ian Kidd, D |
1st | ||||
| Ed Belfour, G |
2nd | ||||
| 1987-88 |
Steve Johnson, C |
1st |
UND All-America Gallery
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
| Buzz Johnson, 1949-50 |
Dan MicKinnon, 1949-50 |
John Noah, 1950-51 |
Ben Cherski, 1951-52, '52-53, '53-54 |
Gerald Schultz, 1953-54 |
Bill Reichart, 1954-55, '55-56, '56-57 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
| Bill Steenson, 1956-57, '57-58, '58-59 |
Reg Morelli, 1959-60 |
Don Ross, 1962-63, '64-65 |
Al McLean, 1962-63 | Dave Merrifield, 1962-63 | Terry Casey, 1965-66 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
| Jerry Lafond, 1966-67 | Terry Abram, 1967-68 | Bob Munro, 1967-68, '68-69 | John Marks, 1968-69, '69-70 | Alan Hangsleben, 1971-72 | Bob Iwabuchi, 1978-79 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
| Kevin Maxwell, 1978-79 | Mark Taylor, 1979-80 | Howard Walker, 1978-80 | Marc Chorney, 1980-81 | James Patrick, 1982-83 | Jon Casey, 1983-84 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
| Scott Sandelin, 1985-86 | Ed Belfour, 1986-87 | Tony Hrkac, 1986-87 | Bob Joyce, 1986-87 | Ian Kidd, 1986-87 | Steve Johnson, 1987-88 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
| Lee Davidson, 1989-90 | Russ Parent, 1989-90 | Greg Johnson, 1990-91, '91-92, '92-93 | Teeder Wynne, 1995-96 | David Hoogsteen, 1996-97 | Curtis Murphy, 1996-97, '97-98 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
| Jason Blake, 1997-98, '98-99 | Karl Goehring, 1997-98, '99-2000 | Jay Panzer, 1998-99 | Brad Williamson, 1998-99 | Lee Goren, 1999-2000 | Jeff Panzer, 1999-2000, '00-01 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
| Travis Roche, 2000-01 | Bryan Lundbohm, 2000-01 | Brandon Bochenski, 2003-04 | Zach Parise, 2003-04 | Taylor Chorney, 2006-07 | Ryan Duncan, 2006-07 |
 |
 |
 |
|||
| Jonathan Toews, 2006-07 | T.J. Oshie, 2007-08 | Chay Genoway, 2008-09 |
